FCA pension fee proposal: explain who pays for the performance
The FCA proposes a pension charge-cap exemption for some performance fees. Clear explanations need to show when a fee arises and which savers bear it.
The brief
The FCA is consulting on exempting certain performance fees from the charge cap for workplace default pensions it regulates. CP26/40, published on 12 November, closes for responses on 14 January 2027; final rules are currently expected in summer 2027. This is a proposal, not permission already in force. The consultation connects the exemption to information sharing, valuation governance and fairness between savers. Our conclusion is that a fee explanation needs to show how a charge arises and who bears it. A statement that a fund charges “only for performance” leaves important questions open. Providers reviewing the proposal should connect their member-facing explanation to the underlying fee terms, valuation evidence and allocation method.
The full record
The current cap is 0.75% for the default workplace pension funds in scope. The FCA proposes an exemption for certain performance fees, seeking closer alignment with trust-based arrangements. Its consultation also proposes safeguards covering disclosure and scrutiny of private-asset valuations. Consultation landing page.
CP26/40 describes a proposed information-sharing term, valuation-governance due diligence and fair allocation of fees between savers. It notes that the period generating a performance fee may differ from the period in which a saver is invested. These are proposals and explanations in the consultation, not a finding that every existing arrangement is unfair. CP26/40, paragraphs 1.13 and 5.2.
Our analysis: make the charging event explainable
A useful explanation starts with the event that earns the fee. Describe what return is being measured, over which period, against which threshold, and after which other costs. Then identify when the fee is calculated and when money is actually deducted. Those dates can matter to a saver joining or leaving during the measurement period.
Keep the explanation tied to a version of the underlying terms. If the method changes, record which version applies to which period and who approved the change. An attractive summary is not enough if the administrator and investment team are using different assumptions about the same fee.
A concrete review exercise
Use a fictional example with two members joining on different dates. Ask the investment team to calculate the charge, the administrator to allocate it, and a communications reviewer to explain the result in ordinary language. Compare their answers. A disagreement identifies an unresolved assumption that should be fixed before the wording is used.
Include a scenario in which an asset valuation changes but no asset is sold. Ask what happens to the proposed fee calculation and what evidence supports the valuation. This is our suggested review method, not a claim that the consultation mandates this exact exercise. It has not been run as a Formal Record benchmark.
The immediate action is to evaluate the proposal and prepare a grounded response where relevant. Do not present expected rulemaking as a settled implementation date, or describe an exemption from a cap as proof of value for an individual saver.
Checked the landing page and relevant consultation passages on scope, transparency, valuation governance and saver fairness on 16 November. This article reports a consultation, not final rules. It does not review the entire cost-benefit model or provide a product recommendation. The numerical exercise is proposed editorial analysis.